in

American Mustache Institute

Protecting the rights of, and fighting discrimination against, mustached Americans by promoting the growth, care, and culture of the mustache.

Follow the AMI

This Blog

Syndication

AMI 2009

Divisive Goldman Tries to Fracture Mustached American Community

Founded in 1965 and the only facial hair advocacy group and think tank in the world, the American Mustache Institute is the standard-bearer for the relatively small and extremely tight knit Mustached American community. This is why other fine groups and individuals in the Mustached American community  -- many of which are charitable in nature -- come to us like the Dons of the early 20th Century for assistance in promoting their exploits.

This includes the likes of Movember, the U.S. Beard Team, Jay Della Valle, TheCheapPop, and Mustaches Vs. Cancer. Another one of these fine groups is Mustaches for Kids -- which of course has in recent years come to AMI to kiss the ring and ask for assistance in promoting its mission.

And that is why it was so disappointing when Mitchell Goldman -- a Brooklyn-based nurse who formed the San Francisco chapter of Mustaches For Kids and soon thereafter joined the New York chapter -- sent what I found to be a very sad e-mail to AMI.

Certainly Goldman, who surprisingly does not go by his middle name of "Jason" as there are only six people named "Mitch" left in North American, should have known better. But instead he sent us a correspondence which in part said:

I’m writing in regards to the AMI’s use of the phrase ‘Stache Bash. Mustaches for Kids owns a trademark registration for ‘Stache Bash, U.S. Registration No. 3,647,024 (as well as U.S. Registrations for Mustaches for Kids and M4K), so I’m requesting that you rename future American Mustache Institute events in order to avoid confusion. 

Very silly.

You see, the hard-liners here at the austere American Mustache Institute appreciate Mr. Goldman's partial-year interest in living the Mustached American lifestyle. And we recognize that in April of 2009 -- several years after the American Mustache Institute held its first 'Stache Bash -- he obtained a "Service Mark" (not a Trademark) for the phrase "'Stache Bash."

But what his Service Mark provides for is "Charitable Fundraising Services, Namely, Organizing And Conducting Charitable Mustache-Growing Events." And thus, from a legal perspective his only request can be that the American Mustache Institute cease to use our annual 'Stache Bash event to benefit Challenger Baseball -- a baseball league for kids and adults with disabilities. And clearly, this is not an option.

Regardless, his request is nonsensical, and we ask you to convey your displeasure to him via e-mail at mitch@mustachesforkids.org, or by mail at 329 Union Street, #3B, Brooklyn, NY 11231.

Be sure to tell him that not only is he unnecessarily becoming a divisive part of the normally harmonious Mustached American community, but that he should simply focus on the good service provided through Mustaches For Kids -- working to ply his trade and do the admirable work that the charity provides.

Carry on. 

 

Comments

 

Jason McElweenie said:

Yes there are D Bags and you are certainly one of the bigger ones

November 13, 2009 11:40 AM
 

Kyle Stone said:

Really, AMI?  Can't leave the discussion behind closed doors, eh? Who do you think is being divisive by airing this laundry and requesting that emails be sent to this guy? You are the ones coming off petty in this.

November 13, 2009 11:58 AM
 

Larry Jones said:

AMI, if there's a D-Bag in this scenario, it's you. If a group like Mustaches for Kids has a service mark on a term like "Stache Bash," then they must defend it. If they don't, they lose their ownership of it and they would have a hard time prosecuting someone who abuses the name. And while AMI is probably using it for good purposes, the fact is M4K owns it and AMI should cease and desist.

November 13, 2009 12:09 PM
 

James said:

Well put, D-bag.  Oh, wait, you were calling THEM D-bags?  I think you have it backwards.  Airing your legal incompetence is always the best way to resolve a seemingly minor dispute.  I'll be sure to recommend your third rate program to all upcoming young litigators.  

November 13, 2009 12:49 PM
 

afroman said:

Gents,

Thank you all for your comments -- both attacking and defending our position and actions in this matter.

Discourse like this is always both constructive and amusing and this event has been no exception.

While the phrase "D-bag" seems a bit unnecessary,  it does add a delicious, flavor-saving element to the conversation.

Carry on.

Dr. Abraham Jonas Froman

Chief Executive Officer

American Mustache Institute

November 13, 2009 2:09 PM
 

Merv said:

I find it deplorable that Mitch would request AMI to cease use of the term Stache Bash. AMI has used the term Stache Bash to the benefit of Challenger Baseball along the way garnering attention from local and national news and other media outlets along with "B" list celebrities to help further the cause of their charitable work.

Mitch I want you to take a long look in the mirror and ask yourself what you are trying to accomplish with your half way thought out selfish ideas.

Carry On

November 13, 2009 3:05 PM
 

Romeo DanceCheetah said:

Glad you brought "flavor-saving" into this.  As a member of Chicago band The Flavor Savers and rocker/attendee of AMI's Stache Bash 2009, I feel I can bring an objective opinion.  With regards to Mitch's comment: "I’m requesting that you rename future American Mustache Institute events in order to avoid confusion" I disagree.  If you attended Stache Bash, you would know that not one kid showed up thinking it was an M4K event...not one.  This alone goes to show that there is no confusion amongst kids for which Stache Bash to attend.  Thank you!

Your D-bag,

Romeo DanceCheetah

Vocalist

The Flavor Savers

November 13, 2009 3:08 PM
 

James said:

You miss the point.  It's not your lack of foresight to protect your intellectual property that makes you a D-bag.  It's the pathetic and juvenille airing of a minor squabble on a blog, clearly designed as a backhanded plea for attention and self-gloss.

Your post has done more to divide this community than the original communication ever could, which probably wasn't your intention, but again; lack of foresight.  

November 13, 2009 3:33 PM
 

Chris said:

Doesn't look like a nonsensical request to me. The service mark is for a charity event called 'stache bash. AMI's event is for charity and uses the same name. Looks pretty clear cut.  The letter seemed friendly enough, not accusing or threatening, so why not work out a solution, you know like people old enough to grow a mustache (i.e. adults).

November 13, 2009 4:04 PM
 

Shenia said:

it's the airing of these back-room politics in blogs and other self-jounalism that helps get public insight into the issue.  every newsperson, blogger and the like has used the same tactic and gotten good insight into the topic for doing it.  whether the lashback was for or against their cause.

the question i have is, why service mark a charitable "event?"  most of the time, these tactics are used by companies protecting revenue-generating assets for the company.  if M4K was raising money for kids, who has time to use the money going for the charity to spend on lawyers protecting trivial things like the name stache bash.

My suggestion is that M4K use their budget to send lawyers after every college fraternity that held a stache bash, every 20-something year old that had a stache bash, and every bar in every city that held a stache bash for charity.

Or...

Leave well enough alone and stick to raising money for the kids.  If someone confuses an AMI Stache Bash for an M4K Stache Bash, does it really matter?  Isn't some kid benefitting from either?

November 13, 2009 4:50 PM
 

Scott Davis said:

Interestingly enough I notice the American Mustache Institute is copyrighted.

November 14, 2009 12:48 AM
 

afroman said:

A fine point by Scott Davis. The difference being, in our case, that we would not send e-mails with legal threats to other people and organizations asking them to not use our language.

In fact, we often allow charities, fraternities, music tours and others to use American Mustache Institute because we fully comprehend that the proliferation of the name only makes it broader.

To wit, at one time or another we also copyrighted:

- "Finger licking good,"

- "What you talkin' 'bout Wills?"

- "Slim, black and dynomite,"

- "Godspeed,"

- and "Neil Diamond."

But this did not have us sending threats of legal action to Kentucky Fried Chicken, Gary Coleman, Jimmy Walker, speechwriters around the world, nor Neil Diamond's parents.

And thus, why this initial request was silly and divisive.

Carry on.

Dr. Froman

November 14, 2009 6:54 AM

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Add

About afroman

Dr. Abraham Jonas Froman is the chief executive officer of the American Mustache Institute. SEe is full bio on the AMI administration page @ http://www.americanmustacheinstitute.org/Administration.aspx
© 2007 American Mustache Institute
Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems